A sportsbook is a state-licensed bookmaker: it sets a price, takes the other side of your bet, and builds its margin into the odds. A US prediction market is a federally registered exchange (a designated contract market, or DCM, overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission) where users trade event contracts that pay $1 if an outcome happens and $0 if it doesn’t. The exchange earns trading fees instead of pricing in a margin. The math of a sports event contract and a sports bet ends up close to identical. The legal status is not: whether states can regulate sports event contracts as gambling is split between federal appeals courts and is now in front of the US Supreme Court.
Legal status below is as checked on Nov 5, 2026. It changes quickly. This page explains the framework; it isn’t legal advice.
The structural differences
| Sportsbook | Prediction market (US DCM) | |
|---|---|---|
| Regulator | State gaming regulator in each legal state | CFTC (federal); states dispute whether they can also regulate sports contracts |
| Who you bet against | The book | Other traders, matched by the exchange |
| How the price is set | The book sets odds | Supply and demand on an order book |
| Where the house makes money | Margin built into odds (the vig) | Trading fees, plus the gap between buy and sell prices |
| Getting out early | Cash-out offers, if the book provides one | Sell your contracts at the current market price |
| Price format | American odds (-110, +150) | Cents per $1 contract (62¢) |
The Third Circuit’s opinion in KalshiEX v. Flaherty describes event contracts as a type of derivative whose value “is determined by market forces,” so the price moves until expiration (opinion, Apr 6, 2026).
Pricing: cents are probabilities
A “yes” contract trading at 62¢ implies a 62% chance. To compare it with a sportsbook price, convert:
- Decimal odds: 1 / 0.62 = 1.613
- American odds: −100 / (1.613 − 1) = -163
Worked side by side, before fees:
| Sportsbook at -163 | Event contract at 62¢ | |
|---|---|---|
| Outlay | $100.00 | 161 contracts × $0.62 = $99.82 |
| Paid if right | $161.35 | 161 × $1.00 = $161.00 |
| Profit if right | $61.35 | $61.18 |
The economics are the same. The difference is where the cost sits. At a sportsbook it’s inside the odds. On an exchange it’s in the trading fees (check each platform’s published fee schedule; we compare them in Kalshi vs Polymarket) and in the spread: if “yes” costs 62¢ and “no” costs 40¢, buying both costs $1.02 for a certain $1.00 payout, a 2-cent spread that does the same job as an overround of 102%.
The conversion formulas are in implied probability in sports betting.
Exiting before the result
Because contracts trade, you can sell before the game ends. If you bought 161 “yes” contracts at 62¢ and the price rises to 75¢ at halftime, selling locks in 161 × $0.13 = $20.93 before fees, whatever happens next. Sportsbook cash-out offers work similarly, but the book sets the cash-out price.
Exchange vocabulary, translated
| Exchange term | What it means | Sportsbook equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Bid | The highest price someone will pay for a contract right now | None; the book quotes one price |
| Ask | The lowest price someone will sell at | The odds you’re offered |
| Spread | Ask minus bid | Part of the vig |
| Maker / taker | A maker posts an order that waits; a taker fills an existing order | None |
| Settlement | Contract pays $1 or $0 when the outcome is determined | Grading the bet |
If you place an order at the ask, you’re the taker and you pay the spread. Posting a lower bid and waiting can get a better price, but it may never fill. Fees can differ between makers and takers, so check the platform’s fee schedule.
Winning bettors: books versus exchanges
At a sportsbook, a consistent winner is the book’s cost. US licensed books keep the right to cut stakes: DraftKings’ Massachusetts house rules let it lower any customer’s maximum payout “for any reason or no reason” (implemented Aug 26, 2025, checked Nov 5, 2026).
On an exchange, your counterparty is another trader and the exchange earns fees either way, so the incentive to restrict winners is different in principle. We couldn’t confirm any US exchange’s written policy on limiting profitable traders, so don’t assume there are no limits. Order book depth is the practical cap: a thin market may not have enough contracts at your price to fill a large order without moving the price against you.
The federal framework
The pieces, from statute to rulemaking:
- Commodity Exchange Act. The CFTC oversees DCMs. Once designated, a DCM can list new contracts by self-certifying that they comply with the law, without pre-approval (7 U.S.C. § 7a-2(c)(1), as described by the Third Circuit).
- The “Special Rule”. The CFTC may bar event contracts that involve unlawful activity, terrorism, assassination, war, “gaming” or similar activity if it finds them contrary to the public interest (7 U.S.C. § 7a-2(c)(5)(C)). Its rule at 17 C.F.R. § 40.11 implements this. The Ninth Circuit’s opinion summarizes § 40.11(a) as categorically prohibiting such contracts that involve gaming (opinion, Aug 28, 2026).
- “Swaps” and exclusive jurisdiction. The CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction over swaps traded on DCMs. The legal fight turns on whether a sports event contract is a “swap” under 7 U.S.C. § 1a(47)(A)(ii) and whether that jurisdiction pushes out state gambling law.
CFTC actions, dated
| Date | Action | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Jun 10, 2024 | Proposed “Event Contracts” rule (would have restricted political and sports-type contracts) | Withdrawn, see Feb 4, 2026 |
| Jan 2025 | Kalshi self-certifies sports event contracts and begins offering them | Ninth Circuit opinion |
| Sep 30, 2025 | Staff Letter 25-36, advisory on sports event contracts | Withdrawn, see Feb 4, 2026 |
| Feb 4, 2026 | CFTC withdraws the 2024 proposal and the 2025 advisory | CFTC release 9179-26 |
| Jun 10, 2026 | Proposed amendments to Rule 40.11: contract-by-contract public-interest review, with definitions of “gaming” and “involve” (91 FR 35806, published Jun 12) | CFTC release 9249-26 |
| Aug 11, 2026 | Emergency order directing Kalshi to keep operating after New York sued it; release lists nine states the CFTC has sued (Arizona, Connecticut, Illinois, Kentucky, Minnesota, New Mexico, New York, Rhode Island, Wisconsin) | CFTC release 9281-26 |
| Oct 9, 2026 | Proposed rule to further define “swap” to expressly include event contracts, including sports (91 FR 66022, published Oct 19) | CFTC release 9310-26 |
Chairman Michael Selig’s position in the October release is that these products are “commodity derivatives squarely within the CFTC’s regulatory remit.” The October proposal’s comment period runs 30 days from Federal Register publication.
The state pushback
States argue that a sports event contract is a sports bet and needs a state license.
- Cease-and-desist letters. Nevada’s Gaming Control Board sent Kalshi one in March 2025, saying it was “operating as an unlicensed sports pool” (per the Ninth Circuit). New Jersey sent one in early 2025, threatening “any measures available under New Jersey law” (per the Third Circuit).
- Lawsuits by states. New York’s attorney general sued Kalshi in state court on Jul 31, 2026 (per the CFTC’s Aug 11 release). Massachusetts’ case against Kalshi was argued at the state’s Supreme Judicial Court on May 4, 2026.
- Collective action. Ohio, 38 other states and the District of Columbia filed a Supreme Court brief on Oct 7, 2026 urging the Court to take the New Jersey case, and say 44 states commented against the CFTC’s June proposal (brief).
The court split
| Court | Decision | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Third Circuit (New Jersey) | KalshiEX v. Flaherty, Apr 6, 2026, 2-1 | For Kalshi: affirmed a preliminary injunction, finding Kalshi had a reasonable chance of success on preemption (opinion) |
| Ninth Circuit (Nevada) | KalshiEX v. Assad, Aug 28, 2026 | Against Kalshi: sports contracts are not “swaps”; the court wrote their substance “is sports gambling, regardless of whether Kalshi calls them swaps” (opinion) |
| Sixth Circuit (Ohio, Tennessee) | KalshiEX v. Schuler, Sep 25, 2026 | Against Kalshi: not swaps, and no preemption in any event (as summarized in the states’ Supreme Court brief) |
| Fourth Circuit (Maryland) | KalshiEX v. Martin, argued May 7, 2026 | Pending as of the states’ Oct 7 brief; we couldn’t confirm a decision as of Nov 5, 2026 |
| Massachusetts SJC | Commonwealth v. KalshiEX, argued May 4, 2026 | Pending as of Oct 7; we couldn’t confirm a decision as of Nov 5, 2026 |
At the Supreme Court: New Jersey’s petition, Flaherty v. KalshiEX, No. 26-299, was filed Sep 2, 2026. On Oct 30, Kalshi’s deadline to respond was extended to Dec 7, 2026, per the official docket. The Court hasn’t decided whether to hear the case. A separate petition by Crypto.com’s US derivatives exchange, No. 26-344, is listed in the states’ brief.
What this means for you
- Availability depends on where you are and can change fast. A platform may offer sports contracts in a state whose regulator says they’re illegal while the case is litigated. Court orders in one circuit don’t settle another.
- Open positions carry legal risk as well as market risk. The CFTC’s Aug 11 order notes that a shutdown could force Kalshi to liquidate open positions.
- Consumer protections differ. State-licensed sportsbooks follow state rules on things like age, complaints and responsible gambling. On an exchange, the rules are the exchange’s and the CFTC’s. Read the platform’s own terms on eligibility, fees and settlement.
- The math is portable. Implied probability, no-vig prices and expected value work the same way on both. If a contract at 62¢ is worth more than 62% to you after fees, it’s the same positive-EV logic as a sportsbook price above fair.
We compare individual platforms’ published fees, markets and regulatory status in best prediction markets for sports.
FAQ
Is a prediction market legal where I live? It depends on the platform, the contract and your state, and federal courts disagree. Check the platform’s terms and your state regulator’s statements, and see a lawyer if it matters. This page isn’t legal advice.
Are prices better on prediction markets? Sometimes. Compare the all-in cost: convert the contract price to odds, add fees, and compare with the best licensed sportsbook price for the same outcome.
Can I lose more than I paid for a contract? When you buy a contract, your maximum loss is what you paid plus fees, because it settles at $0 or $1.
Sports betting and event-contract trading are for adults only; check your state’s age rules and each platform’s terms. For support, call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (National Problem Gambling Helpline), and see our responsible gambling page.